Three-year-old used cars are selling for a record dollar amount below their original sticker prices, according to Edmunds.
Vehicles of that age sold for an average of $32,039 in the third quarter, compared with an average original manufacturer’s suggested retail price (MSRP) of $48,601, the automotive research and shopping platform said in a Nov. 17 analysis.
The $16,562 difference was the largest in Edmunds’ records, surpassing the previous high of $16,252 in the fourth quarter of 2019.
The widening gap marks a sharp departure from the pandemic-era market, when unusually high demand for used cars pushed resale values closer to what they were originally listed for.
In the third quarter of 2022, three-year-old vehicles sold for an average of $9,567 below their original MSRP, according to Edmunds. That was almost $7,000 smaller than the current gap.
The gap is widening partly because original prices have climbed. The average MSRP of the vehicles in Edmunds’ analysis rose about 19 percent between the third quarter of 2022 and the third quarter of 2026, while their average used selling price rose just 2.5 percent.
Used Cars Remain Expensive
Despite the record gap, Edmunds said used-car prices remain historically high.
In the third quarter, the average transaction price for three-year-old vehicles rose 3.1 percent from a year earlier, though it fell from $32,461 in the second quarter.
“The record gap between original sticker prices and used values highlights how much the market has shifted since the pandemic, but it doesn’t change the reality that used vehicles remain expensive,” Edmunds says.
Slower Sales May Help Buyers
Three-year-old vehicles took an average of 43 days to sell in the third quarter, up from 38 days in the previous quarter. According to Edmunds, that was the longest selling time for any third quarter in at least a decade.
“With the fourth quarter typically bringing slower used-car sales, vehicles already sitting on dealer lots for extended periods could present opportunities for shoppers willing to negotiate,” the authors wrote.
Separate data from automotive research firm Cox Automotive show slowed demand across the broader used market. In October, retail used-vehicle sales fell an estimated 1.3 percent from a year earlier and 2.5 percent from September.
According to Cox, the average used-vehicle listing price was $27,133, down slightly from September but 4.9 percent higher than a year earlier. That figure represents a broader range of vehicle ages and is based on asking prices rather than MSRP.
Financing Adds Pressure
Even with lower purchase prices, buyers still face high borrowing costs.
Edmunds’ separate third-quarter financing report, released in October, showed that those who took out a loan to buy used cars paid an average annual percentage rate of 10.6 percent, compared with 7 percent for new-car buyers.
Used-vehicle loans averaged $30,703, with monthly payments of $582 and repayment terms of about 70 months.
Cheaper options are also becoming harder to find. In October, inventory of used cars priced below $15,000 fell 19.3 percent from a year earlier, according to Cox.
Those budget-friendly vehicles averaged just 34 days of supply, 15 days faster than the overall used-market average of 49 days, Cox said.





















