An appeals court blocked the Department of Transportation from withholding $73 million in federal funding from New York because the department lacked legal authority.
The Department of Transportation withheld the funds, claiming New York failed to limit how long commercial driving licenses issued to foreign drivers remained valid.
According to the court’s majority opinion, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) determined that the licenses were supposed to expire on the same date as the driver’s legal presence documents. It also claimed that New York failed to limit how long these licenses stay valid.
The Second Circuit Court of Appeals sided with New York and ruled on Nov. 13 that the regulation never actually included this requirement for commercial driver’s licenses (CDL).
Roughly 50 percent of non-domiciled CDLs and commercial learner’s permits, out of a sample set of 200, were found to have remained valid even as the driver’s legal residence status in the country had expired, according to a 2025 review of New York’s licensing program by the FMCSA.
In December 2025, the Department of Transportation asked New York to immediately revoke every license illegally issued to foreign drivers, or it would cut off funding.
In March this year, FMCSA announced that New York failed to take corrective action and cancel all noncompliant, non-domiciled CDLs and commercial learner’s permits, after which the agency withheld more than $73 million from New York in April.
New York subsequently sued FMCSA, the Department of Transportation, and related officials that month, arguing that FMCSA’s decision was “arbitrary and capricious” and “not in accordance with law.”
Title 49 of the Code of Federal Regulations requires CDLs to remain valid for up to eight years after issuance, applying to both non-domiciled and domiciled CDLs. Nothing in the regulation “requires the States to link the license’s expiration date to an applicant’s lawful status,” the ruling said.
FMCSA’s “position runs afoul of fair notice principles, departs from the regulatory text,” the judges said.
A Department of Transportation spokesperson said that it makes no sense for states to let trucking licenses for foreign drivers stretch years beyond when they are legally in the United States.
“Why would any state want to give unvetted, unqualified foreign drivers trucking licenses that stretch years beyond their lawful status? It makes no sense,” the spokesperson told The Epoch Times.
“We’ve put a stop to the madness to keep the driving public safe. The Trump Administration will continue to use every resource at our disposal to stop illegal immigrants who can’t properly operate a truck from terrorizing America’s roads.”
New York Attorney General Letitia James said in a Nov. 14 post on X, “Once again, @GovKathyHochul and I stood up to defend New York against the harms coming from this administration and won.”
Crackdown on CDL Fraud
The Trump administration’s action against New York is part of a wider crackdown on CDL fraud. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said in July that more than 24,000 drivers had been taken off the roads for failing to speak English, while multiple states were forced to cancel more than 28,000 licenses issued illegally to foreign drivers.
The FMCSA removed almost 10,000 commercial driver training providers from its training provider registry for failing to meet required standards.
Between Jan. 20, 2025, and Oct. 28, 2026, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) made 1,233 arrests involving CDL holders, the Department of Homeland Security said in a Nov. 2 statement.
There have been multiple instances of illegal immigrant truck drivers causing fatal accidents in the United States.
Immigration officials arrested a Kyrgyzstan national in February this year after his truck allegedly hit a van and killed four people in Indiana. An illegal immigrant truck driver was accused in August last year of causing a crash that killed three individuals in the state of Florida.
ICE launched a tipline in September for reporting fraud involving CDLs, Homeland Security announced in a Sept. 9 statement.
The Associated Press contributed to the report.




















