Alberta Appeal Court Dismisses Class-Action Over COVID-19 Lockdown Losses

By Jason G. Antonio
Jason G. Antonio
Jason G. Antonio
Jason Gerald Antonio is a reporter based in Saskatchewan.
November 16, 2026Updated: November 16, 2026

The Alberta Court of Appeal has dismissed a class-action lawsuit by business owners seeking financial compensation for losses incurred during the COVID-19 pandemic lockdowns.

Two Alberta business owners were the lead plaintiffs in a claim for undisclosed millions of dollars in provincewide compensation for losses caused by business restrictions and closures imposed under public health orders, according to the Nov. 13 appeal court decision, as first reported by Blacklock’s Reporter.

The proposed class action covered Alberta business owners whose operations were fully or partially closed or restricted by pandemic public health orders beginning March 17, 2020.

The three-judge panel ruled that although Alberta’s pandemic restrictions had previously been declared unlawful because Cabinet, rather than the chief medical officer of health, made the final decisions, the plaintiffs failed to establish that this procedural violation caused their financial losses.

“If the identical CMOH Orders had been issued by the Chief Medical Officer or her statutorily authorized delegate, as required by the Public Health Act, there would be no negligent act and no claim,” the judges said.

The panel overturned an October 2024 Court of King’s Bench decision that certified the class action and allowed claims of negligence, misfeasance in public office, and violations of the Alberta Bill of Rights to proceed. The lower court had appointed café operator Christopher Scott as the representative plaintiff after finding the proposed claims met the requirements for certification.

The lawsuit followed a 2023 King’s Bench ruling that certain COVID-19 public health orders were unlawful because Cabinet made decisions reserved for the chief medical officer under the Public Health Act. However, that court found the restrictions constitutionally justified, meaning the legal defect concerned who made the decisions rather than the restrictions themselves.

Plaintiffs’ Arguments

Lead plaintiffs Rebecca Marie Ingram and Christopher Scott argued that Alberta had a duty to respect their property rights and follow the law when imposing restrictions.

They relied on the Alberta Bill of Rights, which protects the enjoyment of property and prohibits deprivation of that enjoyment without due process of law. They argued that Cabinet’s unauthorized decision-making violated those protections and caused financial harm to businesses.

The plaintiffs also alleged that Cabinet knew it lacked legal authority to make the final decisions on public health orders but proceeded anyway. They claimed the government attempted to conceal its involvement and shift public criticism onto health officials.

According to the judgment, the plaintiffs alleged that Cabinet used the chief medical officer as a political shield rather than issuing similar orders under the Emergency Management Act. They argued that Cabinet deliberately exercised authority it did not possess while knowing its actions would likely harm business owners.

The plaintiffs also sought a declaration that Alberta violated their property rights by issuing orders without proper legal authority.

Province’s Arguments

Alberta argued that the plaintiffs had not established legally viable claims and that government regulatory decisions generally involved duties owed to the public rather than individual businesses.

The province also cited legal protections for government officials acting in good faith, disputed whether the proposed claims raised sufficient common issues, and challenged whether a class action was the preferable way to resolve the dispute.

Furthermore, Alberta argued that the procedural violation did not cause business losses because the chief medical officer had testified that she supported her recommendations and had not signed orders imposing restrictions more severe than she considered necessary.

The Court of Appeal agreed that the plaintiffs could not demonstrate that business losses resulted from Cabinet’s improper involvement rather than the restrictions themselves.

The judges said unlawful government action does not automatically establish a right to compensation, since plaintiffs must demonstrate that the unlawful conduct caused their losses. They also found no reasonable basis to conclude that the chief medical officer would have imposed fewer restrictions had Cabinet not made the final decisions.

“If anything, the proposed representative plaintiffs may have benefitted from CMOH Orders made by Cabinet that were less restrictive than if the final decision had been made by the Chief Medical Officer,” the judges said.

The court also found that the plaintiffs’ bad-faith allegations faced serious legal obstacles, although it did not determine whether Cabinet acted in bad faith because the claim already failed on causation. Moreover, the judges said the plaintiffs had already obtained a declaration that the public health orders were invalid, making another declaration of little practical value.

“A further declaration, without providing additional remedies, is of little practical utility and does not justify the use of limited court resources,” the panel said.

The Canadian Federation of Independent Business said in a 2021 report that seven in 10 small businesses accumulated roughly $135 billion in new debt due to the pandemic, averaging almost $170,000 per business.